Pony's Irish Pub

Pony's Irish Pub, nestled in Middleport, NY, is rapidly becoming a cherished spot for those seeking a true bar experience with a spirited Irish charm. Patrons rave about the wings and chicken fingers, often labeled "the best in the world," echoing sentiments from satisfied customers like Cody and Billy. With offers like the expansive family boxes, which provide generous portions of tenders and sides for under $60, it's no wonder Leah touts the pub as a must-visit. The menu is diverse, featuring enticing starters such as battered mushrooms and jalapeño poppers, alongside hearty entrees like the classic cheeseburger and the beloved fish fry. Kevin praises the ownership for creating an inviting atmosphere, perfect for unwinding after work or catching a game. However, not every experience hits the mark; an isolated review by Pjangles illustrates that service can vary, especially during busy events. Still, overall, Pony's Irish Pub delivers on flavor and value, making it a top recommendation for both locals and visitors in search of a convivial dining experience. Don’t miss out on their vibrant drinks and delectable food offerings—it may just become your new favorite haunt.